How to Minimize the Stickiness of Water Based Lube
It seems logical to add more lube because what you are using dissipates. This can actually make the problem worse by causing it to gum up even faster. Keep a glass of water by the bed and add it as needed to revitalize your water based lube as it dries up. The addition of water won’t keep your lube from eventually drying out, but it will lengthen the amount of time it takes before it gets excessively sticky.
It sounds like you want to completely avoid dried up, sticky situations. For that, I suggest using either silicone lube or coconut oil.
Silicone Lube
Silicone based lubricants contain no water. So, they never dry up. They have a slick feel that’s long lasting, and are safe to use with latex condoms. Silicone lubes aren’t absorbed by the skin. They require a soap and water to be completely removed from the body. Because silicone doesn't wash away with plain water, it’s the perfect lubricant for shower, pool, or hot tub sex. The price of silicone lube is higher than water based, but because a little goes a very long way, you’ll use a lot less and one bottle will last you much longer.
Some silicone lubes are known to stain fabrics. That is something to keep in mind if you plan on having a romp on top of your fancy duvet. Another downside of silicone lubricant is that it can sometimes react negatively with silicone sex toys and damage them. As a general rule of thumb, most toy manufacturers recommend never using silicone lube with silicone toys. Although some silicone toy and silicone lube combinations work perfectly well together, the only way to find out is to experiment, which may put your toys at risk.
